November 24, 2021 Via Federal eRulemaking Portal Public Comments Processing United States Fish and Wildlife Service 5275 Leesburg Pike Falls Church, VA 22041-3803 Re:Regulations for Listing Endangered and Threatened Species and Designating Critical Habitat, Docket No. FWS-HQ-ES-2019-0115 Dear Secretary Haaland: The Animal Welfare Institute ("AWI") submits the following comments in support of the proposal of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service ("USFWS") to rescind the final critical habitat exclusion regulations that were added to the implementing regulations of the Endangered Species Act of 1973, 16 U.S.C. §§ 1531–1544, ("ESA" or "Act"), and became effective in January 2021, 85 Fed. Reg. 82,376 (Dec. 18, 2020) ("Final Rule"). 86 Fed. Reg. 59,346 (Oct. 27, 2021). The Final Rule leaves areas that are essential to species' recovery unprotected, which places listed species in peril, undermining ESA implementation. AWI therefore supports the Services' proposed regulation to rescind the Final Rule and resume full implementation of the Policy and the regulations at 50 C.F.R. § 424.19. AWI supports rescission of the Final Rule for four primary reasons: (1) the Final Rule is arbitrary and capricious; (2) the Final Rule is more restrictive than the plain language of the ESA and reduces conservation of species' habitat;(3) the Final Rule provides extractive industries with undue influence in the critical habitat designation process; and (4) critical habitat designations do not significantly reduce private development. For a detailed discussion of these four issues, please see the attached document. Sincerely, Johanna Hamburger Director and Senior Staff Attorney Terrestrial Wildlife Program Animal Welfare Institute
FWSRulemakingFWS-HQ-ES-2019-0115
Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Revision of the Regulations for Designating Critical Habitat
RIN
—
Last modified
Aug 30, 2022
Comment window
closed 1688d ago
Animal Welfare Institute filings
1
Activity
Animal Welfare Institute filed 1 comment on this docket between Nov 26, 2021 and Nov 26, 2021. 41 other organizations filed here. The comment window closed 1688d ago.
What Animal Welfare Institute filed (1)
Nov 26, 2021· Comment from Animal Welfare Institute· FWS-HQ-ES-2019-0115-41254
Abstract
No abstract recorded.
View on regulations.gov →Co-filers (41)
See everyone who commented →- Animal Welfare InstituteTHIS ORG1 filing · confidence 97%
- Association of Metropolitan Water Agenciestrade assoc.3 filings · confidence 97%
- Association of Fish and Wildlife Agenciestrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Southern Environmental Law Center (SELC)2 filings · confidence 97%
- American Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- American Petroleum Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- American Road & Transportation Builders Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- Arizona Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- Budd-Falen Law Offices LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Defenders of Wildlife1 filing · confidence 97%
- Eastern Oregon Counties Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Edison Electric Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- Energy and Wildlife Action Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Family Farm Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Forest Landowners Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Golden Eagle Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- GPA Midstream Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- Independent Petroleum Association of Americatrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Montana Native Plant Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- MT Native Plant Society 10082020trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Association of Home Builderstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- National Endangered Species Act Reform Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Mining Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- National Wildlife Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- New Mexico Federal Lands Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Northwest Hydroelectric Association and National Hydropower Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Pacific Legal Foundationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Public Lands Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Solar Energy Industries Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Southern Resource Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- The Nevada Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- The Petroleum Alliance of Oklahomatrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- The Wildlife Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- U.S. Chamber of Commerce1 filing · confidence 97%
- University of Colorado Law Schoolunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Western Energy Alliance and American Exploration & Production Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Western Urban Water Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Wildlife Conservation Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Williamson County Conservation Foundationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Wyoming Association of Conservation Districtstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Wyoming County Commissioners Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%