EPARulemakingEPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0517

Prevention of Significant Deterioration/Title V Greenhouse Gas Tailoring Rule

RIN

—

Last modified

Mar 8, 2022

Comment window

closed 5312d ago

Environmental Defense Fund filings

Activity

Environmental Defense Fund filed 1 comment on this docket between Apr 23, 2012 and Apr 23, 2012. 242 other organizations filed here. The comment window closed 5312d ago.

What Environmental Defense Fund filed (1)

Apr 23, 2012· Comment submitted by Pamela A. Campos, Environmental Defense Fund et al.· EPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0517-19292

Attached please find comments from Center for Biological Diversity, Clean Air Task Force, Environmental Defense Fund, Natural Resources Defense Council, and Sierra Club

View on regulations.gov →

Abstract

Applicability thresholds for greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions under the PSD and Title V programs of the Clean Air Act.

View on regulations.gov →

Co-filers (242)

See everyone who commented →

Environmental Defense FundTHIS ORG
1 filing · confidence 97%
N. Counciltrade assoc.
4 filings · confidence 85%
National Association of Manufacturers (NAM)trade assoc.
4 filings · confidence 97%
American Chemistry Counciltrade assoc.
3 filings · confidence 97%
Interstate Natural Gas Association of Americatrade assoc.
3 filings · confidence 97%
Renewable Fuels Associationtrade assoc.
3 filings · confidence 97%
DRT Mfg. Companyunverified attribution
2 filings · confidence 70%
Edison Electric Institutetrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 97%
Georgia Mining Associationtrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 85%
National Alliance of Forest Ownerstrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 85%
National Association of Clean Air Agenciestrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 85%
National Association of Home Builderstrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 97%
National Federation of Independent Businesstrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 97%
National Steering Committeetrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 85%
North American Insulation Manufacturers Associationtrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 85%
Solid Waste Association of North Americatrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 85%
Southern Companyunverified attribution
2 filings · confidence 70%
Spectra Energy Corpunverified attribution
2 filings · confidence 70%
Texas Pipeline Associationtrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 97%
The Council of Industrial Boiler Ownerstrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 85%
The Fertilizer Institutetrade assoc.
2 filings · confidence 97%
A & N Electric Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Ad Hoc Coalition of Small Business Refinerstrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
ADAGE LLCunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Alliance for Climate Protectiontrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Alliance of Automobile Manufacturerstrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
Amalgamated Sugar Company LLCunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Ameren Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
America's Natural Gas Alliancetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
American Coatings Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
American Cool Air Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
American Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
American Forest & Paper Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
American Foundry Societytrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
American Gas Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
American Meat Institutetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
American Petroleum Institutetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
American Public Power Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
and Certified Commercial Investment Members (CCIM) Institutetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
and Solar Turbines Inc.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
and The New Jersey Environmental Federationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Ariel Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Arkansas Environmental Federationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce and Associated Industries of Arkansastrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Association of Electric Companies of Texastrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Attorneys at Law on behalf of Society of Independent Gasoline Marketers of America (SIGMA) and National Association of Convenience Storestrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
BARC Electric Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Basin Electric Power Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Basin Electronic Power Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Bechtel Power Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Belden Brick Co.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Brick Industry Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Business Owners and Managers Association (BOMA) Columbustrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Business Roundtabletrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
Calgon Carbon Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
California Air Pollution Control Officers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
California Council for Environmental and Economics Balancetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
California Forestry Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Calpine Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Carbon Offset Providers Coalitiontrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Cash-WA Distributing Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Center for Biological Diversity
1 filing · confidence 97%
Chairman both of the American Bakers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Charleston Metro Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Cherokee Tobacco Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Citizens Alliance for Responsible Energytrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Clean Air Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
CLECO Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Competitive Enterprise Institutetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Compressed Gas Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
ConocoPhillips Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Corn Refiners Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Counsel to Louisiana Association of Business and Industrytrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
CountryMark Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Craig Botetourt Electric Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Crete Carrier Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Dart Container Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Deere & Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Detroit Regional Chambertrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Dominion Resources Services Inc.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Duke Energy Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
E.ON U.S. LLCunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
East Kentucky Power Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
El Paso Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Elan Technology Inc.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Empire District Electric Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Energy Recovery Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Engine Manufacturers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
First Energy Generation Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
First Energy on behalf of Metropolitan Edison Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
FirstEnergy on behalf of Cleveland Electric Illuminating Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
FirstEnergy on behalf of Pennsylvania Electric Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
FirstEnergy on behalf of the Jersey Central Power & Light Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
FirstEnergy on behalf of the Ohio Edison Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
FirstEnergy on behalf of Toledo Edison Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Flexible Packaging Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Gary-Williams Energy Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Gas Processors Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Georgia Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Georgia Motor Trucking Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Georgia Poultry Federationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Glass Packaging Institutetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
GLOBALFOUNDRIES U.S. Inc.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Golder Associates Inc. (Golder) on behalf of The Florida Sugar Industryunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Greater Elkhart Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Greater Medina Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Greater North Fulton Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Greenville Chambertrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Harper Construction an Edwards and Wiggins Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Hickman Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Idaho Association of Commerce & Industrytrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Inc. (formerly Motorola Semiconductor Products Sector)unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Inc. on behalf of Interlocking Concrete Pavement Institutetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA) on behalf of International Association of Drilling Contractorstrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Indiana Cast Metals Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Indiana Universityunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Institute for Libertytrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Intel Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
International Dairy Foods Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
Iowa Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Iowa Renewable Fuels Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
J. M. Murphy and Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
J.R. Simplot Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Kansas Agribusiness Retailers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Kansas Association of Ethanol Processorstrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Kansas Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Kansas Grain and Feed Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP on behalf of the Association Coalitiontrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Kelley Drye & Warren LLP on behalf of Specialty Steel Industry of North America (SSINA) and Steel Manufacturers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Laclede Gas Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Lafarge North America Inc.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Landmark Legal Foundationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Large Public Power Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Latham & Watkins LLP on behalf of National Climate Coalitiontrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Lignite Energy Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
LLC on behalf of Eco Power Solutions (USA) Corp.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
LLP for Semiconductor Industry Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Louisiana Propane Gas Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Maine Motor Transport Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Marathon Oil Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Mass Comment Campaign sponsored by Alliance for Climate Protection (39trade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Mass Comment Campaign sponsored by National Wildlife Federation (NWF) (5trade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Mass Comment Campaign sponsored by Penneco Oil Co. Inc. (10)unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
McNairy County Economic Development Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
MDU Resources Groupunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
MeadWestvaco Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
MidAmerican Energy Holdings Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Mississippi Manufacturers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Missouri Public Utility Alliancetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Monmouth County Audubon Societytrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Montana Building Industry Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Montana Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Montana Contractors' Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Montana Stockgrowers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Murphy Oil Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Murray Energy Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
National Association of Clean Water Agencies (NACWA)trade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
National Association of Homebuilderstrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
National Black Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
National Cotton Ginners Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
National Environmental Development Association's Clean Air Project (NEDA/CAP)trade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
National Federation of Independence-Arkansas Chaptertrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
National Grain and Feed Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
National Lime Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
National Mining Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
National Paint and Coatings Association/ Federation of Societies for Coatings Technology (NPCA/FSCT)trade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
National Petrochemical & Refiners Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
National Pork Producers Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
National Retail Federationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
National Rural Electric Cooperative Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
National Solid Wastes Management Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
National Tribal Air Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)trade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
Nebraska Chamber of Commerce & Industrytrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Nebraska Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Newmont Mining Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
North America Inc.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
North American Coal Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
North Carolina Automobile Dealers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Northwest Mining Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Nucor Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Ohio Coal Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association.trade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Old Dominion Electric Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
on behalf of Peabody Energy Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
on behalf of Pennsylvania Power Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
on behalf of The National Climate Coalitiontrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Penobscot McCrum LLCunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
PLLC on behalf of the National Environmental Development Association's Clean Air Projecttrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Portland Cement Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
Prince George Electric Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Princeton Universityunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Rappahannock Electric Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Red Cedar Gathering Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Regal Rubber Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Rubber Manufacturers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
Salt Lake Chambertrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Schmit Industriesunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Semiconductor Industry Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 97%
Shenandoah Valley Electric Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Small Business & Entrepreneurship (SBE) Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
South Carolina Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
South Dakota Trucking Association (SDTA) and South Dakota Automobile Dealers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Southern Illinois Power Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Southside Electric Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Steve Meyers for General Electric Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Sunflower Electric Power Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Sustainable Forest Action Coalitiontrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Teaching and Training Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Tennessee Chamber of Commerce & Industrytrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Tennessee Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Texas Association of Businesstrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Texas Chemical Council (TCC) and Texas Association of Manufacturerstrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Texas Cotton Ginner's Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Texas Instruments Incorporatedunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Texas Oil and Gas Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
The Chamber of Commerce of Southwest Indianatrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
The Dow Chemical Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
The National Turkey Foundation (NTF) and the National Chicken Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
The Ohio Cast Metals Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Treated Wood Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) for the Department of Defenseunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
U.S. Inc.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Union of Concerned Scientistsunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
United States Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
University at Buffalounverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
University of Californiaunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
URS Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Utility Trailer Manufacturing Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Valero Energy Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Van Ness Feldman on behalf of the Coalition for Emission Reduction Projectstrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Verizon Communications Inc.unverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Virginia Manufacturers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
West Virginia Automobile & Truck Dealers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
West Virginia Manufacturers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
West Virginia Oil and Natural Gas Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Western Sugar Cooperativeunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Westlake Chemical Corporationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Weyerhaeuser Companyunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
William & Jensen PLLC for Energy-Intensive Manufacturers Working Group on Greenhouse Gas Regulationunverified attribution
1 filing · confidence 70%
Window & Door Manufacyturers Associationtrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%
Wyoming Outdoor Counciltrade assoc.
1 filing · confidence 85%