Clcl11@aol.com 04/16/2003 09:32 PM To:CWAwaters@EPA cc: Subject: Re: Comments on Proposed Rulemaking for CWA EPA Water Docket ID # OW-2002-0050 Mailcode 4101T 1200 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Washington, DC 20460April 16, 2003 Re: Comments on Proposed Rulemaking for CWA The League of Women Voters of Watauga (LWV-W) would like to submit comments on the Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking regarding the Clean Water Act. The League is committed to clean water, and supports water resource programs that deal with water quality & quantity in surface & groundwaters. We endorse policies that bring about good water quality, which is vital for maintaining aquatic species. These include the protection of lakes, streams, and wetlands from pollution resulting from direct, as well as non-point sources. Wetlands are a vital part of clean water protection, and since wetlands in our region are few and small in acreage, any potential loss of protection should not occur without thorough review and public input. The League opposes the Proposed Rulemaking. According to the Clean Water Act, we interpret the definition "waters of the U.S." to mean all waters, large and small. The proposed ruling would remove federal jurisdiction from many waters that are now protected by the Act. Intermittent streams and wetlands play an important part in biological diversity. They function as an interconnected system, and impairment to one part could potentially harm the function of the whole. Since the CWA has been implemented, there has been much progress in restoring the nations waters. The new ruling would have an impact on wetlands, creeks, and streams. The Corps and EPA staffs would no longer have jurisdiction over "isolated" waters. This could open the way for industry and developers to argue about many ponds and wetlands as being "isolated". This would allow for even more destruction and pollution. We would urge the Administration to continue to protect all waters currently under the CWA. Thank you for considering our comments. Sincerely, Cathy Landy, Conservation Chair, LWV-W
Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on the Clean Water Act Regulatory Definition of "Waters of the United States" with the Joint Memorandum providing guidance.
Activity
League of Women Voters filed 3 comments on this docket between Apr 7, 2003 and Apr 16, 2003. 143 other organizations filed here. The comment window closed 8548d ago.
What League of Women Voters filed (3)
Mary <rkelly1@sc.rr.com> 04/15/2003 04:36 PM To:CWAwaters@EPA cc: Subject:Attn: Docket ID No. OW-2002-0050 Mary T. Kelly, Ph.D. Natural Resources Representative League of Women Voters of the Columbia Area 4018 Sandwood Drive, Columbia, SC 29206 April 15, 2003 Water Docket Environmental Protection Agency Mailcode 4101T 1200 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Washington, D.C. 20460 Attention Docket ID No. OW-2002-0050 Re: Docket OW-2002-0050 Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on the Clean Water Act Regulatory definition of "Waters of the United States." Dear Sir or Madame: These comments are being submitted by the League of Women Voters of the Columbia Area, a non-profit organization of active volunteers working to enhance the overall mission of the League: to facilitate the active participation of citizens in their government. Our organization on all levels -local, state and national - has long been an advocate for the strong clean water legislation and rule making that have been so effective in cleaning up our nation's waterways and protecting our wetlands. As citizens of a state with a large acreage of wetlands including those termed isolated wetlands we understand the problems that will and are arising related to the preservation of the isolated wetlands. Without the wetlands habitat is lost, recreational opportunities are curtailed, flooding is exacerbated and pollutant filtering is diminished. The proposed changes to the Clean Water Act rules by the US EPA and the US Army Corps of Engineers go far beyond any changes made necessary by the US Supreme Court's ruling in the Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County (SWANCC) and would harm the ability of the state and EPA to protect our invaluable natural resources. We join with the SC Wildlife Federation, the Sierra Club, and other responsible environmental organizations in urging you not to proceed with the rulemaking and to focus on implementing the narrow interpretation of SWANN being promoted by the US Department of Justice. Sincerely, Mary T. Kelly, Natural Resources Representative, LWV Columbia Area Cynthia Flynn, President, LWV Columbia Area
Filed on regulations.gov — full text not in the inline record.
Abstract
Contact: Donna Downing, USEPA/OW/OWOW, (202) 566-1366, HQ
View on regulations.gov →Co-filers (143)
See everyone who commented →- League of Women VotersTHIS ORG3 filings · confidence 97%
- "Comment from Conservation Advisory Counciltrade assoc.4 filings · confidence 85%
- Comments for 68 FR 1991 entitled "Comments from the Association of State Wetland Managers"trade assoc.3 filings · confidence 85%
- "Keep Army Corp Out of Isolated Waters"unverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- American Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 97%
- Conservation Law Foundationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Federal Water Quality Coalition.trade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Juniata Valley Audubon Society.trade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- National Association of Home Builderstrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 97%
- Raymond Proffitt Foundation.trade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Sierra Club2 filings · confidence 97%
- South Cuyahoga Sportsmen's Association.trade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Southern Appalachian Forest Coalition.trade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- The Foundation for Environmental and Economic Progresstrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- 'Interstate Council on Water Policy Comments on ANPRM on Definition of "Waters of the United States"'trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- " Comments of Waterkeeper Alliance"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on the Clean Air Act Regulatory Decisions of 'Waters of the United States'" sponsored by National Association of Home Builderstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on the Clean Water Act Regulatory Definition of 'Waters of the United States'" sponsored by St. Tammany Home Building Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on the Clean Water Act" sponsored by National Association of Home Builderstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Comments from Santa Clara Valley Audubon Society"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Comments from Western Chapter Society of Wetland Scientists"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Comments of the California Farm Bureau Federation"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Domestic Petroleum Council (DPC) Comments on SWANCC Decision Implementation"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Kittitas Audubon Society comments"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Protect isolated wetlands and water systems"unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- "Questions regarding economic effects and treatment of hydrologic systems"unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- "SC Wildlife Federation Comments"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- "Vernal Pools are not Isolated Systems"unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Alliance for Affordable Energy.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Alyeska Pipeline Service Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials. File 1 of 2.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials. File 2 of 2.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- and Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Associations.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA).trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Association of State and Interstate Water Pollution Control Administrators (ASIWPCA).trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Audubon Society of New Hampshire.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Austin Audubon Society.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Bio-Reaction Industries.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Black Hills Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Building Industry Legal Defense Foundation ("BILD")trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Chevron Texaco Corporation.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Chuck Wemple of Galveston Bay Foundation.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Coalition for Habitat Conservation.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Delaware Nature Society.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Exeter River Local Advisory Committee.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 entitled " Western Water Alliance Comments on CWA ANPR"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 entitled "Comment of Farmers Reservoir and Irrigation Company"unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- for 68 FR 1991 entitled "Comments of LA Mid-Continent Oil and Gas Association"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 entitled "Grand Canyon Wildlands Council Comments on OW-2002-0050"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 entitled "Huron River Watershed Council recommends inclusive definition of U.S. waters"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 entitled "Nebraska Wildlife Federation ANPRM comments"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 entitled "Nebraska Wildlife Federation comments on ANPRM"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 entitled "State Association of Kansas Watersheds(SAKW) Jurisdictional Challenge"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 entitled "Utah Farm Bureau Federation Comments on Regulatory Definition of "Waters of the United States"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Aggregate Industriesunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Alexandra Dawson of MA Association of Conservation Commissions.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Alexis Duxbury on behalf of the North Dakota Natural Science Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Association of State Wetland Managers entitledtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Bob Perciasepe on behalf of the Audubon Society (400+ similar letters received)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Caren Cowan on behalf of the New Mexico Cattle Growers' Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Cathy Shropshire on behalf of the Mississippi Wildlife Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Chris Hesla on behalf of the South Dakota Wildlife Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Christopher Howard on behalf of the Blue Mountain Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from DeGraaf Adams and Teresa Battenfield on behalf of the Galveston Bay Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Gary Lutterbie on behalf of the Illinois Chapter of the American Fisheries Society.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from George Hawkins on behalf of the Stony Brook Millstone Watershed Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Jim Wood on behalf of the Yell County Wildlife Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from John Baughman on behalf of the International Association of Fish and Wildlife Agenciestrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Jule B. Gill of the Tucson Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Kenneth P. Corhan on behalf of Lewis Operating Corp.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- for 68 FR 1991 from L. Terry Conner on behalf of the Tahoma Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Lawrence M. Page on behalf of the American Society of Ichthyologists and Herpetologiststrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Lena Gallitano on behalf of the Wake Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Linda A. Falasco of the Construction Materials Association of Californiatrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Michael Andoscia on behalf of the Responsible Growth Management Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Nancy W. Sommer on behalf of the Audubon Society of Forsyth Countytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Sandra McNew/Aiken Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Steve Noble on behalf of the Central Minnesota Builders Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Teri J. Pieper on behalf of the Central Basin Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Terry W. Horton on behalf of the Arkansas Wildlife Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from the Foundation for Environmental and Economic Progresstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Tom Partin on behalf of the American Forest Resource Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from Walt Carnahan on behalf of the Sierra Foothills Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991 from William Gill/Tucson Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- for 68 FR 1991entitled "Detroit Audubon Society comments"trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Golden Gate Audubon Society.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Inc. ("ICC").unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Indiana Water Quality Coalition and the Indiana ManufacturersAssociation.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Iowa Environmental Council.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Izaak Walton League.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Lamprey River Advisory Committee.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- League of Ohio Sportsmen ~ Ohio Wildlife Federation.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Lewis Operating Corp.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- LLP on behalf of Building Industry Association of Superior California.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Maine Association of Wetland Scientists.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mass Association of Conservation Commissions.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mass Comment Campaign entitled "30 Year History" sponsored by Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Material Services Corporation.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Mississippi Farm Bureau Federation (MFBF).trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mohave County Professional Registrants Association.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Association of Industrial and Office Propertiestrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Cattlemen's Beef Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- National Wildlife Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Nebraska Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Nevada Mining Association. File 1 of 2.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Nevada Mining Association. File 2 of 2.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Nevada Wildlife Federation.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- New Hampshire Wildlife Federation.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- New Mexico Cattle Growers Association (NMCGA).trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- North Carolina Association of Environmental Professionals (NCAEP).trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Northern Plains Resource Council.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Occidental International Corporation.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Oregon Cattlemen's Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Oregon League of Conservation Voters.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Pilchuck Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Powder River Basin Resource Counverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Sand & Gravel Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Save the Dunes Council.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Senate Environmental and Public Works Committee.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Shea & Gardner on behalf of Newmont Mining Corporation.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Shea & Gardner on behalf of the Newmont Mining Corporation.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Skagit System Cooperative.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- South Yuba River Citizens Leaguetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Southeast Michigan Council of Governmentstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Southeastern Section of the Wildlife Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Tennessee Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- The Canadian Nature Federation.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- the Corporation Commission Oil & Gas Conservation Division.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- The Wildlife Management Institute. File 1 of 2.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- The Wildlife Management Institute. File 2 of 2.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Three Island Rural Council.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- University of Georgia. File 1 of 2.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- University of Georgia. File 2 of 2.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- University of Houston - Law Center.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- University of Tennesseeunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Vancouver Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Warkentin Partnership.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Washington Legal Foundationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Washington Universityunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Washington Wildlife Federation and the Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Associationstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Wayne State Universityunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Wyoming Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Wyoming Outdoor Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Yell County Wildlife Federation.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%