September 30, 2014 Ben Supko Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration U.S. Department of Transportation West Building, Ground Floor, Room W12-140 Routing Symbol M-30 1200 New Jersey Avenue SE. Washington, D.C. 20590 Re: Docket No: PHMSA-2012-0082 (hm-251): Hazardous Materials: Enhanced Tank Car Standards and Operational Controls for High-Hazard Flammable Trains Dear Mr. Supko, The National Mining Association (NMA) submits the following comments in response to the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administrations (PHMSA) notice of proposed rulemaking to improve the regulations applicable to the transportation of hazardous materials by rail. The National Mining Association (NMA) is a national trade association that includes the producers of most of the nations coal, metals, industrial and agricultural minerals; the manufacturers of mining and mineral processing machinery, equipment and supplies; and the engineering and consulting firms, financial institutions and other firms serving the mining industry. NMAs members ship their products by rail throughout the United States and could be significantly impacted by the PHMSAs proposed rule. In fact, coal and mineral shipments account for over half of the total tonnage shipped by Class I railroads and approximately 30 percent of total gross freight revenue. Although the proposed rule applies primarily to the rail transportation of crude oil and ethanol, the nationwide footprint of the proposal could significantly impact the shipment of commodities which are not the focus of the rule, including those produced and transported by NMA members. Under the proposed rule, PHMSA would implement a nationwide speed limit of 50 miles per hour for all High Hazard Flammable Trains (HHFT) and a 40 mile per hour speed restriction for any HHFT unless all cars containing flammable liquids meet or exceed the standards proposed by DOT. While NMA supports efforts of PHMSA, the rail industry, and its shippers to develop safety protocol that protect our communities from the risks associated with the transportation of highly flammable materials, it is important to do so in an efficient and measured way. The trains subject to these restrictions share track with those carrying a host of other commodities of which NMA members comprise the total majority. As an interconnected network, the effects of the lost velocity on the rail network would be felt by all rail customers increasing transit times, costs to shippers, and resulting in greater railway congestion. Consequently, available growth capacity of the entire network could be significantly reduced and make adjusting for disruptions like severe weather increasingly difficult. Restoring the capabilities of the existing network could take many years and billions of dollars in additional capital expenditures. NMA encourages PHMSA to work with the rail industry and others to put in place essential safeguards without unnecessary and significant impacts to the interconnected community of rail customers. Thank you for considering these comments. Should you have any questions please feel free to contact me at (202) 463-2643 or aeckman@nma.org. Respectfully submitted, Adam Eckman Associate General Counsel National Mining Association
PHMSARulemakingPHMSA-2012-0082
Hazardous Materials: Rail Petitions and Recommendations to Improve the Safety of Railroad Tank Car Transportation
RIN
—
Last modified
Jul 8, 2016
Comment window
closed 3910d ago
National Mining Association filings
1
Activity
National Mining Association filed 1 comment on this docket between Oct 29, 2014 and Oct 29, 2014. 154 other organizations filed here. The comment window closed 3910d ago.
What National Mining Association filed (1)
Oct 29, 2014· National Mining Association - Comment· PHMSA-2012-0082-3375
Abstract
Hazardous Materials Railroad Tank Cars
View on regulations.gov →Co-filers (154)
See everyone who commented →- National Mining AssociationTHIS ORG1 filing · confidence 97%
- Association of American Railroadstrade assoc.3 filings · confidence 97%
- Dangerous Goods Advisory Counciltrade assoc.3 filings · confidence 85%
- National Railroad Passenger Corporationunverified attribution3 filings · confidence 70%
- Riverfront Park Associationtrade assoc.3 filings · confidence 85%
- American Chemistry Counciltrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 97%
- American Petroleum Institutetrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 97%
- American Short Line and Regional Railroad Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Archer-Daniels-Midland Companyunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- Center for Biological Diversity2 filings · confidence 97%
- Eastman Chemical Companyunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- Formosa Plastics Corporationunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- Grain Processing Corporationunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- Hess Corporationunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- Illinois Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Institute of Makers of Explosivestrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 97%
- National Industrial Transportation Leaguetrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- National Shippers Strategic Transportation Counciltrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- North America Freight Car Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Railway Supply Institutetrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Renewable Fuels Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 97%
- The Chlorine Institutetrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- The Dow Chemical Companyunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- The Fertilizer Institutetrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 97%
- :L.G. Everist Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Agri-Empresa LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Almatis Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- American Association for Justicetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- American Association of Port Authoritiestrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- American Association of Private Rail Car Ownerstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- American Exploration & Production Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- American Iron and Steel Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- American Plant Food Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- American Public Transportation Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- American Water Works Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- Arkema Incunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Arthur N. Ulrich Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Association of American Railroads and American Short Line and Regional Railroad Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Association of State Rail Safety Managerstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Association of Washington Citiestrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Axiall Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Banks Lumber Co.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Bartlett Grain Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- BASF Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Bay Area Houston Economic Partnershiptrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Bayer Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- BNSF Railway Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Brandt Company Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Caljet of America LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Canadian Association of Railway Supplierstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Carbondale City Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Cascade Warehouse Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Celanese Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Charlotte Pipe and Foundry Company Plastics Divisionunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Chemical Industry Council of Illinoistrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- City Fibers Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Clark Fork Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Cloud Peak Energy Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- CML Metals Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Colorado Lava Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Columbus Region Logistics Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Committee on Tank Carstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Compressed Gas Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Cooper Tire & Rubber Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Council on Safe Transportation of Hazardous Articlestrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Dakota Gasification Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Diamond B. Construction Company LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Domestic Energy Producers Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Eighty-Eight Oil LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Exxon Mobil Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Fiesta Warehousing and Distribution Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- FMC Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Fort Laramie Oil-by- Rail Safety Committeetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Fort Worth Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Glacier Two Medicine Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- GLNX Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Great Northern Midstream LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Honeywell Performance Materials and Technologiesunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Honorable Mayor and Berwyn City Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- IL & TRAC Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Illinois and the TRAC Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Illinois Manufacturers’ Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- In Situ Oil Sands Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Inc. and Citizens for Waterunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Independent Fuel Terminal Operators Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Independent Petroleum Association of Americatrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Industrial Packaging Alliance of North Americatrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- INDY Chambertrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Inland Empire Paper Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Institute of Shortening and Edible Oilstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Intermodal Association of North Americatrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- International Association of Fire Fighterstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- James River Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- LB Foster Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- League of California Cities appreciatestrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- League of Women Voterstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- Lori Fisher ( Lake Champlain Committee)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Louisiana Railroads Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Maine Municipal Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- McCain Foods USA Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Mercatus Center at George Mason Universityunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Michigan Corn Growers Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Murphy Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Musket Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- National Association of Towns and Townshiptrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Fire Protection Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National League of Citiestrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Pasta Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Propane Gas Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- New Progressive Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- NIK Non-Stock Marketing Cooperativeunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Norfolk Iron and Metal Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- North Dakota Petroleum Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Northern Plains Resource Council.trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Odyssey Logistics & Technology Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- PBF Energy Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industrytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry (PA Chambertrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Petroleum Association of Wyomingtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Plasmine Technology Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Rail Service Incorporatedunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Railway Supply Institute Committee on Tank Carstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Reagent Chemical & Research Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Region 10 Tribal Operations Committeetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Reinke Grain Company Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Sacramento Area Council of Governmentstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Safe Energy Leadership Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- San Joaquin Partnershiptrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Seneca Sawmill Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Shintech Incorporatedunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Sierra Frac Sand LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Silbrico Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- SMBC Rail Services LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Solvay USA Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- South Suburban Mayors and Managers Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Spears Manufacturing Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- State for Passenger Rail Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Stimson Lumber Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- The Kansas City Southern Railway Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- The Scoular Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- The Sulphur Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Timber Products Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Tripak Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Tube City IMS Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- U.S. Chamber of Commerce1 filing · confidence 97%
- Union Pacific Railroad Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Vinyl Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Virginia Chamber of Commercetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Wabtec Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Wasatch Clean Air Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Washington Dungeness Crab Fishermen's Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Waterkeeper Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%