Please accept these public comments from 115,095 online members and activists on behalf on the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) regarding EPA-R10-OW-2017-0369 opposing the Pebble Mine. The mine would be disastrous for the Bristol Bay watershed, putting world-class salmon fisheries and jobs created by them at risk of contamination from mining waste. It is vital to protect the Bristol Bay watershed, the health of communities and the environment from this toxic mine and for these reasons we urge you to stop the Pebble Mine. Thank you.
Proposal to Withdraw Proposed Determination to Restrict the Use of an Area as a Disposal Site; Pebble Deposit Area, Southwest Alaska
Activity
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) filed 5 comments on this docket between Aug 9, 2017 and Oct 24, 2017. 95 other organizations filed here. The comment window closed 3206d ago.
What Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) filed (5)
Filed on regulations.gov — full text not in the inline record.
On behalf of the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and our more than 3 million members and activists, attached please find detailed comments opposing in the strongest terms EPA's Proposal to Withdraw the Proposed Determination. Instead of withdrawing, NRDC urges EPA finalize its Proposed Determination, or, in the alternative, to maintain the Proposed Determination as a guideline for permitting. Such action would be responsive to science, justified by law, and clearly permissible under EPA's congressionally-instilled Clean Water Act authority. It is also overwhelmingly supported by the Bristol Bay residents, subsistence families, commercial fishermen, business owners, and countless individuals whofor over a decadehave sought EPA protection of Bristol Bay's pristine environment and productive fishery.
Filed on regulations.gov — full text not in the inline record.
Filed on regulations.gov — full text not in the inline record.
Abstract
The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Administrator and Region 10 Regional Administrator are requesting public comment on whether to withdraw the EPA Region 10 July 2014 Proposed Determination that was issued pursuant to Section 404(c) of the Clean Water Act, to restrict the use of certain waters in the South Fork Koktuli River, North Fork Koktuli River, and Upper Talarik Creek watersheds in southwest Alaska as disposal sites for dredged or fill material associated with mining the Pebble deposit, a copper-, gold-, and molybdenum-bearing ore body. EPA agreed to initiate this proposed withdrawal process as part of a May 11, 2017 settlement agreement with the Pebble Limited Partnership (PLP), whose subsidiaries own the mineral claims to the Pebble deposit.
View on regulations.gov →Co-filers (95)
See everyone who commented →- Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)THIS ORG5 filings · confidence 97%
- American Fisheries Societytrade assoc.3 filings · confidence 85%
- Defenders of Wildlife3 filings · confidence 97%
- Alaska Trollers Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Bristol Bay Economic Development Corporationunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- Bristol Bay Native Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Quadco LLCunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- Air Liquide America Corpunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Akutan Traditional Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Alaska Chambertrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Alaska District Council of Laborerstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Alaska Forest Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Alaska Marine Conservation Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Alaska Miners Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Alaska Senate Resources Committeetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Alaskan City of Manokotak the Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Alatna Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Aleknagik Traditional Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Allakaket Village Tribal Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- American Exploration & Mining Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- American Fly Fishing Trade Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- American Petroleum Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- Analytics and Publication DentaQuest Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Anchorage Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- and Ekwok Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Anvik Tribal Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Arkansas Valley Audubon Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Atmautluak Traditional Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Barry University School of Lawunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Borell Consulting Services LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Bristol Bay Native Association for Bristol Bay Marine Mammal Council (BBMMC) and Qayassiq Walrus Commissiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Bristol Bay Native Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Calista Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Center for Biological Diversity1 filing · confidence 97%
- Chickaloon Native Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Chignik Bay Tribal Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Chuathbaluk Traditional Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- City counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Copper Country Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Council Chairpersontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Council of Alaska Producerstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Counsel on behalf Ekwok Village Council (EVC) and Bristol Bay Fishermen's Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Ekuk Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Ekwok Natives Limited Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- EPA Region 10’s Tribal Operations Committeetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Essency Environmental LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Evansville Tribal Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Eyak Preservation Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Gagnon Howe & Co. LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Holy Cross Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Howard Fabrication Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Huslia Tribal Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- JCV Services LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Kachemak Bay Conservation Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Kasigluk Traditional Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Kongiganak Traditional Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Leber Jeweler Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Mass Comment Campaign sponsored by Alaska Wilderness League. (web)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mass comment campaign sponsored by Bristol Bay Native Corporation (BBNC) (web)unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Mass comment campaign sponsored by National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA). Sample attached (email)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mass comment campaign sponsored by National Wildlife Federation Action Fund (web)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mass Comment Campaign sponsored by National Wildlife Federation. Emailtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mass Comment Campaign sponsored by The Pebble Partnership (web)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Michigan State Universityunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Montana State Universityunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- National Mining Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- National Parks Conservation Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Tribal Water Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Wildlife Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Nenana Native Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- New Koliganek Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- New Stuyahok Traditional Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Newhalen Tribal Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Nondalton Tribal Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- North Star Terminal Stevedore Co. LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Northway Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- on behalf of Pebble Limited Partnershiptrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- One Fish Foundationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Petersburg Indian Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Pilot Point Native Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Pilot Point Tribal Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Port Graham Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Portage Creek Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Roaring Fork Fishing Guide Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Saguyak Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Sea Port Products Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Southeast Alaska Conservation Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Sun'aq Tribal Council Chairtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- The Barker Adoption Foundationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Tribal Caucus Memberstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- TundraLove LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Twin Hills Village Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- U.S. Chamber of Commerce1 filing · confidence 97%
- University of California Santa Cruzunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Westport Charterboat Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Wrangler Cooperative Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%