The Northwest Horticultural Council (NHC) submits the following comments regarding the U.S. Food and Drug Administrations (FDA) proposed rule entitled Standards for the Growing, Harvesting, Packing, and Holding of Produce for Human Consumption; Extension of Compliance Dates for Subpart E, published in the Federal Register under docket number FDA-2011-N-0921. The NHC represents apple, pear, and cherry growers, packers, and shippers in Idaho, Oregon, and Washington on federal and international policy and regulatory issues. Our members grow, pack, and ship approximately 77 percent of the fresh apples, 84 percent of the fresh pears, and 78 percent of the fresh cherries produced in the United States. We support this proposed rule to delay compliance dates for Subpart E of the Standards for the Growing, Harvesting, Packing, and Holding of Produce for Human Consumption (Produce Safety rule). Since the initial draft of the Produce Safety rule was released in 2011, the NHC has communicated to FDA that the requirements in Subpart E are overly burdensome, complicated, and costly for growers to implement, while providing little benefit to public health. We appreciate FDAs acknowledgement of stakeholder concerns regarding the practicability of these provisions, and the agencys commitment to using this proposed delay in compliance dates to reevaluate Subpart E in its entirety. Thank you for the opportunity to provide comment. We look forward to continuing to work with FDA to develop a workable approach to ensuring that water used in agricultural production is of adequate microbial quality for its intended use. Sincerely, Kate Woods Vice President Northwest Horticultural Council
FDARulemakingFDA-2011-N-0921
Standards for the Growing, Harvesting, Packing, and Holding of Produce for Human Consumption
RIN
—
Last modified
Sep 24, 2024
Comment window
closed 1638d ago
Northwest Horticultural Council filings
3
Activity
Northwest Horticultural Council filed 3 comments on this docket between Jan 7, 2014 and Nov 17, 2017. 172 other organizations filed here. The comment window closed 1638d ago.
What Northwest Horticultural Council filed (3)
Nov 17, 2017· Comment from Kate Woods, Northwest Horticultural Council· FDA-2011-N-0921-19155
Dec 15, 2014· Comment from Northwest Horticultural Council· FDA-2011-N-0921-1271
Northwest Horticultural Council comments on FDA-2011-N-0921 attached:
Jan 7, 2014· Comment from Northwest Horticultural Council· FDA-2011-N-0921-0361
Attached are final comments from the Northwest Horticultural Council concerning the proposed rule. Disregard prior submission.
Abstract
Open
View on regulations.gov →Co-filers (172)
See everyone who commented →- Northwest Horticultural CouncilTHIS ORG3 filings · confidence 97%
- National Sustainable Agriculture Coalitiontrade assoc.7 filings · confidence 85%
- Farm and Ranch Freedom Alliancetrade assoc.5 filings · confidence 85%
- National Onion Associationtrade assoc.5 filings · confidence 85%
- Cornucopia Institutetrade assoc.4 filings · confidence 85%
- Idaho Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.3 filings · confidence 85%
- Idaho-Oregon Fruit and Vegetable Associationtrade assoc.3 filings · confidence 85%
- Maine Organic Farmers and Gardeners Associationtrade assoc.3 filings · confidence 85%
- The Cherry Marketing Institutetrade assoc.3 filings · confidence 85%
- American Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 97%
- American Herbal Products Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Carolina Farm Stewardship Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Consumer Federation of Americatrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Elise Woods Morgan County Association for Food and Farmstrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Farmers Market Federation of New Yorktrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Florida Fruit and Vegetable Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 97%
- Hawaii Farmers Union Unitedunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- Illinois Stewardship Alliancetrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Maine Farm Bureau Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Malheur County Onion Growers' Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Massachusetts Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Michigan Organic Food and Farm Alliancetrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- National Water Resources Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Oklahoma Food Cooperativeunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- Oregon Fresh Market Growers Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Pacific Northwest Vegetable Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Powder River Basin Resource Counciltrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Produce Marketing Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Rice Fruit Companyunverified attribution2 filings · confidence 70%
- the Farmers Market Coalitiontrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- U.S. Apple Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- United Fresh Produce Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Washtenaw Food Policy Counciltrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Western Agricultural Processors Associationtrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Wild Farm Alliancetrade assoc.2 filings · confidence 85%
- Agri World Cooperativeunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Agricultural Council of Mainetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Almond Hullers & Processors Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Amagansett Food Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- American Chemistry Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- American Mushroom Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- and Weston A. Price Foundationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Be Wise Ranch Incunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- BioLogic Systemsunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- BrynTeg Farm LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Burden Farming Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- California Fresh Fruit Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Cassie Noltnerwyss Crossroads Community Farm LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Center for Small Farms and Community Food Systemsunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Central Valley Almond Association INCtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Chert Hollow Farm LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Chilean Fruit Exporters Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Citrus Australia Ltdunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Clayton Vincent National Watermelon Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Community Alliance with Family Farmerstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Conservation Law Foundationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- CROPP Cooperativeunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- David Marvel (Fruit and Vegetable Growers Association of Delaware)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Deluge Farm LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Dundee Citrus Growers Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Environmental Defense Fundtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- Equal Exchange Incunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Fairview Produce Auction Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Family Farm Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Farm and Ranch Freedom Alliance Multiple Submitters 17072 Total Form Letter Comment(Multiple Submitters=17trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- First Nations Development Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- FL Citrus Packers/Indian River Citrus Leaguetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Flagstaff Liberty Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Florida Water Enviroment Association Utility Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Food Marketing Institutetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Food Processing Suppliers Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Fresh Produce Association of the Americatrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Fresh Produce Association of the Americastrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Georgia Fruit and Vegetable Growers Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Grower-Shipper Association of Central Californiatrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Harvest Sun Farm LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Hawaii Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Idaho Onion Growers' Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- IL Farmers Market Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Institute for Agriculture & Trade Policytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Iowa Farmers Unionunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- J Robert Connor Linnaen Farm LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Jack Kittredge The Northeast Organic Farming Association Massachusetts Chapter Inctrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- John Dewar North Country Grown Cooperativeunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Juice Products Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Keep Food Legal Foundationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Kentucky Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Lindsay Corporationunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- LLC Bownsunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Malheur County Onion Growers Association and Idaho Onion Growerstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mendocino County Food Policy Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mercatus Center at George Mason Universityunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Michigan Apple Committeetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Mingo County Diabetes Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Minor Crop Farmer Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Asparagus Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Association of Conservation Districtstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Council of Farmer Cooperativestrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Farmers Unionunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- National Milk Producers Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- National Onion Association NOAtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Organic Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Potato Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 97%
- National Sunflower Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Water Users Association (Moffatt Thomas Barrett Rock & Fieldstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Wildlife Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Wooden Pallet & Container Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- National Young Farmers Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Native American Food Sovereignty Alliancetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Nature's Harvest Organic Farm LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Nebraska Farmers Unionunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- New England Farmers Union NEFUunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- New Hampshire Public Health Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- New Mexico Food and Agriculture Policy Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- New Zealand Ministry for Primary Industriesunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- NH Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- North Carolina Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- North Dakota Grain Growers Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- North East Biosolids and Residuals Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Northeast Organic Farming Association - Interstate Council Policy Committeetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Northeast Organic Farming Association of New Yorktrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Northeast Organic Farming Association of Vermonttrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Ohio Ecological Food and Farm Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Ohio Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Oregon Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Oregon State University Extension Small Farms Programunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Organic Consumers Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Organic Produce Wholesalers Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Organic Trade Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Organically Grown Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Outpost Natural Foods Cooperativeunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Paramount Farming Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Pennsylvania Association for Sustainable Agriculturetrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Pennsylvania Association of Staff Nurses and Allied Nurse Professionalstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Petoskey Harbor Springs Area Community Foundationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Pollinator Partnershiptrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Raisin Bargaining Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Recirculating Farms Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Request for Extension from Powder River Basin Resource Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Responsible Farmers Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Rhode Island Agricultural Partnershiptrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Richard Pasichnyk The Living Cosmos Societytrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Rincon-Vitova Insectaries Inc.unverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Rural Advancement Foundation International - USAtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Santa Fe Food Policy Advisory Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Sharon Yeago LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Southeastern Massachusetts Agricultural Partnershiptrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- State Horticultural Association of PAtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- State Horticultural Association of Pennsylvaniatrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Tennessee Farm Bureau Federationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Texas International Produce Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- the Administrative Committee for Pistachiostrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- the Honorable Charles K Scott Bates Creek Cattle Companyunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- The Packers of Indian River Ltdunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- The Snack Food Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Traci Potter Fins County Rail Farm LLCunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- Tuscarora Organic Growers Cooperativeunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- U.S. Chamber of Commerce1 filing · confidence 97%
- United Fresh Produce Association - Request for Extension oftrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- University of California’s Small Farm Programunverified attribution1 filing · confidence 70%
- US Apple Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- US Composting Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Vermont Tree Fruit Growers Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Vermont Vegetable & Berry Growers Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Virginia Association for Biological Farmingtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Washington Growers Clearing House Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Washington Organic Recycling Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Willamette Farm and Food Coalitiontrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Wisconsin Organic Advisory Counciltrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Write in Campaign from National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition ( Individual Consumers)trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Write in Campaign Re: The Cornucopia Institute Individual Consumerstrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Write-In Campaign 1a re Cornucopia Institute (Multiple Submitters=4trade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%
- Yuma Fresh Vegetable Associationtrade assoc.1 filing · confidence 85%